Jump to content
  • Sign Up
Mike profile photo

promoters - event reviews?

Site Stuff Mike

 
Posted

Currently looking at changing the way on here the way that the promoter (the event details poster) can post reviews on their own event....

as in  going for a 'no reviews by promoter please' policy

the thinking is that by having such a policy it could help make the reviews feature more worthwhile and more useful to both members and promoters

the promoter can still answer any points raised by members reviews via our 'reply to review' feature that only shows to the promoter (the event details poster)

any thoughts?

  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

Makes sense Mike. (Always feels a bit uncomfortable giving our own do a star rating)

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

Too many comments said by some involved at venues I've been too that leave me wondering if we were at the same venue.  I take little notice of anything said by someone involved, unless I was there and can agree so any points system or other on here holds little credence for me.

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted (edited)

Agree . To make reviews more objective and independent perhaps exclude also those djing at said event particularly 'residents' ? 

Edited by andybellwood
  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

thanks for views so far 👍

 

though maybe looking at this from the wrong angle - maybe it would work better if we scrap the star rating system ?

 

  • Up vote 3

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
5 hours ago, PhilT said:

Makes sense Mike. (Always feels a bit uncomfortable giving our own do a star rating)

You don't have to Phil. We as the punters do it for you . 

Steve 

  • Up vote 3

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
17 minutes ago, mike said:

thanks for views so far 👍

 

though maybe looking at this from the wrong angle - maybe it would work better if we scrap the star rating system ?

 

I would. Just leave itv to reviews only. Folk can see if those posting have a vested interest or genuine people who had a good night. 

  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
19 minutes ago, Winsford Soul said:

You don't have to Phil. We as the punters do it for you . 

Steve 

Yeah, we just like to say thanks to folk Steve so not a review at all  really. (Good to see you mate, as always).

  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

top night you lovely people , it was a great night  award yourselves the highest stars lol!!!

  • Up vote 1

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

If you have to review your own event then it must've been pants, by definition if you have to tell folks you're cool you're not.

Other people will tell you when and IF you are!

  • Up vote 1

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

I reckon people can post what they want, promoters or otherwise. None of us are idiots, it's as plain as a bootleg when the people posting five stars and raving or waxing lyrical are completely deluded. To say people who promote or DJ at an event can't comment is going a little too far. Scrap the star system if you feel that would help. Like Phil said, we like to thank people who turn up and make our night what it is and we have 'awarded' ourselves fewer stars in the past when we had a one off sound issue and would do again in a heartbeat if it was pants. All it takes is to turn up at an event to see if the reviews are justified x

 

  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
9 minutes ago, jumpinjoan said:

I reckon people can post what they want, promoters or otherwise. None of us are idiots, it's as plain as a bootleg when the people posting five stars and raving or waxing lyrical are completely deluded. To say people who promote or DJ at an event can't comment is going a little too far. Scrap the star system if you feel that would help. Like Phil said, we like to thank people who turn up and make our night what it is and we have 'awarded' ourselves fewer stars in the past when we had a one off sound issue and would do again in a heartbeat if it was pants. All it takes is to turn up at an event to see if the reviews are justified x

 

Also the ‘HOT’kudos in comments etc when clearly it’s the same person or same two people commenting. Especially the promoter , I just find that a bit pointless especially when it’s something like “2 days to go “! 

  • Up vote 3

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted (edited)

The link to all events says if you attended you can make a review  ! 

And that must mean Promoters also  !

Not fussed about star rating 

 

 

 

 

Edited by Kev John
  • Up vote 1

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

I also keep forgetting to add my star rating and wonder for two days why I can't see my review 🙄

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
34 minutes ago, chalky said:

I also keep forgetting to add my star rating and wonder for two days why I can't see my review 🙄

I've done this too Chalky. People often post a review in the pre-event comment section instead of the review part without realising. Maybe revert back to the old system where it just follows on in one long thread? 

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
1 hour ago, jumpinjoan said:

I've done this too Chalky. People often post a review in the pre-event comment section instead of the review part without realising. Maybe revert back to the old system where it just follows on in one long thread? 

I think the old way was best

  • Up vote 1

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

Agree. I think some people still put their reviews in the pre-event part, rather than the review part. And I kind of like the whole thread to morph from before a night to after the event - All read as one project.

That's my view anyway - Others may think differently (and is of course why Mike has asked for people's thoughts)

I vote scrap the star rating. Although a good idea in theory, in practice it doesn't seem to be very beneficial (Leave the star ratings to 'TripAdvisor') 

Len :thumbsup:

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

again thanks for all the views so far

all helpful and appreciated👍

changes are a lot more deliberate nowadays so need to give it all a  bit of thought and planning

will post in this forum in advance any planned tweaks etc

 

 

 

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

ok here's the current plan...

looking at tweaking the event display back to the 'default' layout

that means the comments will show all the time - to read reviews you will then need to the 'review' tab on the page or click a 'review' link 

by doing this, this  will allow promoters, attendees etc to comment after events without having to post a 'faux' review while keeping reviews going but as a more stand alone feature with an improved focus for members to use them to review the events. With promoters will then be asked not to 'review' own events 

the review feature will keep the stars  for now as it would be too much of a technical issue/effort to remove them from the 'review' feature and the use may improve as it will be a more stand alone feature

that's the plan, will start putting it in place shortly

cheers now

mike

 

  • Up vote 1

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted

Nice move, I personally do like the star rating although it has its drawbacks. It just got really dreary seeing every review with 5 stars along the lines of "another great night, thanks for coming, see you next month" didn't tell you anything really except that the promoter was a happy bunny. 

 

  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted (edited)

I’m also now looking forward to more informative and factual reviews  which will either encourage or dissuade me from visiting new venues or those I haven’t been to for a while . Hopefully I won’t continue to read ‘it gets better’...’the best one yet ‘ for the same venue repeated month after month , or the price of (cheap ) beer , yet no mention of the music played . Just some examples . 🤣

Edited by andybellwood
  • Up vote 4

Share this source music forum post


soul source url
Posted
13 hours ago, andybellwood said:

I’m also now looking forward to more informative and factual reviews  which will either encourage or dissuade me from visiting new venues or those I haven’t been to for a while . Hopefully I won’t continue to read ‘it gets better’...’the best one yet ‘ for the same venue repeated month after month , or the price of (cheap ) beer , yet no mention of the music played . Just some examples . 🤣

Hate to see people pushing the fact that the Beer is cheap !

  • Up vote 2

Share this source music forum post


soul source url

Site Stuff - Support Forum

Site related support and feedback forum

Join Soul Source

A free & easy soul music affair!

Get started now!
Log into Soul Source

Get max use of the forums

Log in now!

Source Adverts



×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.