With regard to what records were played at which venue first the thing I find most frustrating is the lack of dates given with claims. Here are my memories of some of the records referred to by Pep and when, and in some instances where, they were played.
Four Larks
Alan S was playing a Tower issue of this in the early months of 1972.
Roy Hamilton.
I heard talk of this through the summer of '72 but it wasn't played at the Catacombs until September and the re-opening after the Astra refurbishment. Alan Day had it at Up the Junction (Crewe) where I first heard it on August 5th. It was one of the top sounds of that era that you knew on first hearing merited its exalted status. The black RCA issue with Nipper and the phonograph, meant the record looked great as well. I think the orange reissue came out shortly afterwards which led to it being dropped from shortlists before the autumn was out.
The Velours.
Pep brought a demo of this to the Catacombs on a Wednesday night in the summer of '73. The bass led intro, the bells and the soaring chorus prompted instantaneous appeal and two plays that night, which was very unusual for the Cats. The following Saturday the record was accompanied by the mass handclapping of the assembled throng and its iconic status was assured. The other version by Frankie Valli became the version to play by the time Wigan opened in September, but it is but a pale imitation, to my ears at least
Bob Relf.
This was huge. For a couple of weeks, around July '73, this was the most popular record played at the Cats, and that's some accolade when you think of the array of top sounds that graced the decks at that time. Again, a record with a section where the instrumentation is stripped right back and the hand clappers fill the void.
Sam and Kitty
As I recall, around October/November Graham Warr came back from the States from one of his trips and there was a sudden influx of new sounds. George Carrow, The Glories, Johnny Moore, Earl Jackson Soul Twins, among others. Sam and Kitty was one of these and, I must admit for the first few plays I was unimpressed. It didn't stand out particularly but it was a staple item in any DJ set. However, thirty miles north of the Cats in Hose Street, Tunstall, dancefloor reaction was much more enthusiastic. I first went to The Torch in December 1972 and noted that four records stood out in terms of dance floor reaction. Eddie Parker was way out at number 1, but Sam and Kitty, along with The Shakers and The Triumphs, Walking the Duck, all warranted the rush to the dance floor. An impressive sight if you were looking on from the balcony.
Dena Barnes, The Epitome of Sound.
I remember these from the dog days of The Cats in June/ July 1974. Attendances had plummeted since Wigan had opened and the last night was only a couple of weeks away. These were two records that stood out at that time and it is fitting, given the news this week, that I recall a conversation I had with Smokie when I just bumped into him in the town, by St Peter's Gardens. I asked what current sounds met his favour and he referred to these two. A discerning choice with which I could only agree.