Modernsoulsucks

Supremes He's all I got Elgins Heaven Isley Brothers This old Current Live

Yes I agree with what I assume is the point you're making that because of their status they're overlooked by the cognescenti. OK we don't have to hear them everytime we go out but these should be in any self-abusing soul fan's collection so he can flick through them with his other hand. ROD

Supremes He's all I got Elgins Heaven Isley Brothers This old OK P but just to make sure that Johnson 45 is b-side to I'll pick a rose...

And that woulda been a belter of an idea.....had I happened to own a copy of any version which unfortunately I don't. As you have your scientific head on have you drawn any conclusions, other than that most of the contributors shouldn't be allowed out on their own, based on the data provided on this thread. I haven't myself but I thought I'd drop it in your lap in return for posting the Top 500. ROD

So that's now Marv Johnson You got the love I love Supremes He's all I got Elgins Isley Brothers Mark didn't comment on Isleys and Elgins but I have the feeling... 4 Tops may be "What is a man" and I don't have that ROD

Yes he has but we are trying to find a common denominator throughout all collections although it is less likely if you only collect one type with just a smattering of the other. The loss of the Carstairs is a huge blow as I'd convinced myself everybody likes/has it except Pete Smith. Still we've learnt some things along the way foremost amongst which is to ignore completely the next "good idea" from NZ. ROD

Eddie hasn't got the Carstairs!!!!! Or 4 Tops Elgins Heaven Isley Brothers This old

That many eh? Still it was a pretty piss-poor enterprise and you could see Berry Gordy getting nowhere with that sound.

Carstairs It really hurts... Elgins Heaven must have... Isley Brothers This old heart... Four Tops Shake me wake me Current Live 45s

I think he does the odd Motown 45 and bearing in mind your comment re exhausting Top 500 and diminishing returns it may be an idea for Mark to post up those Motown he does have as I woulda thought there's a slim chance of agreement on something from that label. He probably likes Lionel Ritchie as he's into 70's. ROD

Carstairs It really hurts... Elgins Heaven must have... Isley Brothers This old heart... Four Tops Shake me wake me Noted no Shades of Blue, Pete

yes good suggestions. You are aware of rules? If you don't have a copy you say so.

OK I have those and I guess Steve and Pete do so Carstairs It really hurts... Elgins Heaven must have... Isley Brothers This old heart... Four Tops Shake me wake me Mark b may be a problem though

Marvelous!! Do you want to put 5 more up then Steve? ROD

I did see them Steve and had none Im afraid. I've not got any Oscar Perry 45s either so that leaves again Carstairs Red Coach What about Billy Butler Sweet Darlin' Come on over to my side I'll bet you Burning touch of love Theresa Lindsey I'll bet you

And I've got to get the wife's tea on or I'll be for it. She thinks I just mess around on here all day. ROD

Next three please!! Carstairs + ?

Was that Schroedinger's Appreciations. You neither have it nor don't have it. You won't know till you open your record box? ROD

Where have you been!! We've done those ages ago. Suggest a few?

Belles had been eliminated earlier. Mancha's have both gone so still the Carstairs remaining. Someone else put a few forward. Looks like we didn't think much of the new Top 100. Anybody have more than 10? Obviously price came into it with Parliaments etc but if we were all upfront we would have bought them in Wigan record bar for £1.50 ROD

I was still typing I think. Yes everything has gone again apart from Carstairs Red Coach. So two new titles from me Steve Mancha Don't make me a storyteller Steve Mancha You're still in my heart

Voice Masters "If A woman Catches A Fool" Bamboo (Adam D - Chippenham) Brothers Of Soul "I'd Be Grateful" Boo (Mick Howard - Manchester) Robert Parker "I Caught You In A Lie" Nola (Kev H - Mansfield) Appreciations "She Never Really Loved Me" Sport (John D - Wigan) Belles "Don't Pretend" Mirwood (Andy - Bolton) Current list till we hear back from Mikecook. Thanks for that Mike. ROD

Mike are these what you've got from whole 100 list. I've got about as many but different so between us we've wiped it out I think ROD

Jimmy Raye "I Just Can't Take No More" KKC JJ Barnes "Get A Hold Of Yourself" Mickays (Andy Dennison - Musselburgh) Voice Masters "If A woman Catches A Fool" Bamboo (Adam D - Chippenham) Brothers Of Soul "I'd Be Grateful" Boo (Mick Howard - Manchester) Sea Shells " Quiet Home" Village Little Johnny Hamilton "Oh How I Love You" Dore (Toad - Coventry) Kell Osborne "Can't Outsmart A Woman" Loma Robert Parker "I Caught You In A Lie" Nola (Kev H - Mansfield) Silky Hargreaves "Hurt By Love" D Town (Tony P - Heywood) Appreciations "She Never Really Loved Me" Sport (John D - Wigan) Belles "Don't Pretend" Mirwood (Andy - Bolton) That was easy!! We may have had Belles and Jimmy Raye [Philly..] earlier. I'll check in a mo ROD

Just seen that Top 100. I've got hardly any. I'll edit it and post up. Should be down to ten or so no problem. ROD