are there 2 different versions of this?

 

regards

Andy

 

Yes - Richard Searling had an alt version.... I seem to recall.

 

Sean

The two issues on Calla are different mixes/takes.

As far as I was aware the other different take belongs to Butch, he has the studio acetate which has male backing.

i was just talking to someone about it and they pointed out that they had calla 152 not 153, didnt even know there were different versions until now

sorry 142 & 143

143 and 152, different takes.  Both great though, one of the best northern records ever for me and cheap!

and right there is why i like it so much chalky

always knew there were different versions but never compared...ive got 143 but just listened to both on you tube and not sure which one i like best now!..143 is more punchy and drums are more 'northern' i suppose but i do like the doubled up more funky drums and the way she lingers her words a bit on the other...or maybe i just like hearing new things

 

great tune either way

 

dean

i always kept this coz its......well different as well as being good

 

Which take is the Uk copy Dave? Can't listen at moment.

Which take is the Uk copy Dave? Can't listen at moment.

its from the west indies chalky but it says calla  143 on it

Cheers Dave. Just said Uk as couldn't read the text.

So which version is on the CD album ??  (& why weren't both takes included as that seems to have every other track she cut for Calla on it). 

So which version is on the CD album ??  (& why weren't both takes included as that seems to have every other track she cut for Calla on it). 

i was just going through the CD & my JW 45s & i think there are a couple more of the Calla sides missing, so that is just one of the missing ones I suppose.  Does seem a bit odd to not put everything on there though, but there must be reasons.