Someone should be able to help with this.

Are the Volumes on Garu the same group as recorded on Inferno/ImpactAmerican Arts.

Cheers in advance

Kev

Don't think so Kev ....according to my information....courtesy of the Detroit Soul index...ala Keith Rylatt, which lists American-Arts,Astra,Chex,Impact,Inferno,Karen, Old Town, and Twirl....Best wilxy

Don't think so either Kev

Garu was out of San Antonio

Wasn't there an article on the Volumes/Magnetics as a front page article on here last year with all the info on the Detroit group?

Cheers

Richard

Edited May 1, 201114 yr by Premium Stuff

The group on Garu is a local San Antonio chicano soul group.

Cheers guys. Clears that one up for me.

Best

Kev

Edited May 2, 201114 yr by Kev Moore

i still say the vocalist on the am i losing you.... the flip of aint gonna give you up is the same fellow who sings on magnetics lady in green and count the days on sable... but not on when im with my baby....... just listened again and im still totally convinced

dave

course dave, it's that mckinney fellow, innit?

bri pinch

no bp i think lee mckinney did the lead on when i`m with my baby and i`ll keep holding on

dave

Edited May 2, 201114 yr by dave pinch

i still say the vocalist on the am i losing you.... the flip of aint gonna give you up is the same fellow who sings on magnetics lady in green and count the days on sable... but not on when im with my baby....... just listened again and im still totally convinced

dave

the Magnetics were the Volumes if thats what your getting at.

Volumes on Garu different group as far as I'm aware.

PRETTY MUCH SO CHALKS..............LOTS OF PEOPLE HAVE TRIED TO TELL ME DIFFERENT OVER THE YEARS BUT YOUR THEORY IS THE SAME AS MINE

DAVE

Bob-A did a great interview with the Sable Magnetics (Sitting In The Park)? where John Lee and Andrew Griffin the other singer (who sang Count The Days and when I'm With My Baby) were interviewed for an hour. Lee sings CTD backed by Andrew.

Edited May 2, 201114 yr by Prophonics 2029

i still say the vocalist on the am i losing you.... the flip of aint gonna give you up is the same fellow who sings on magnetics lady in green and count the days on sable... but not on when im with my baby....... just listened again and im still totally convinced

dave

Dave - I thought the lead singer on the Magnetics 'Lady in Green' was Gerald Mathis who also sang lead for the Volumes on 'That Same Old Feeling'/'The Trouble I've Seen' on Impact.

I don't think the lead on the Volumes 45 on Karen was Gerald - it was a different guy - Eddie Union maybe?

Weren't the Chicago Magnetics on Sable etc a different group?

Cheers

Richard

Edited May 2, 201114 yr by Premium Stuff

Dave - I thought the lead singer on the Magnetics 'Lady in Green' was Gerald Mathis who also sang lead for the Volumes on 'That Same Old Feeling'/'The Trouble I've Seen' on Impact.

I don't think the lead on the Volumes 45 on Karen was Gerald - it was a different guy - Eddie Union maybe?

Weren't the Chicago Magnetics on Sable etc a different group?

Cheers

Richard

i really think they moved about a bit. you`re right about gerald mathis on the volumes on impact and magnetics on bonnie.... but its also definately him on count the days and am i losing you on karen but he doesn`t sing on the flips.... weather he was ghosting or not i`m not sure.... but there`s no one else on the planet who sounds like him its 100% nailed on

dave

Dave - I thought the lead singer on the Magnetics 'Lady in Green' was Gerald Mathis who also sang lead for the Volumes on 'That Same Old Feeling'/'The Trouble I've Seen' on Impact.

I don't think the lead on the Volumes 45 on Karen was Gerald - it was a different guy - Eddie Union maybe?

Weren't the Chicago Magnetics on Sable etc a different group?

Cheers

Richard

Chicago Magnetics are a different group to the Detroit Magnetics.

Chicago Magnetics are a different group to the Detroit Magnetics.

[/quot

but just listen to count the days chalks... different vocally to the other sable cuts and then go listen to lady in green, same old feeling.. definately the same singer whatever the people in the `know` say

dave

Edited May 2, 201114 yr by dave pinch