This might be interesting. We just did this on another music board with LPs & ended up not even being able to find a common artist let alone single LP on a board of collectors with seemingly similar tastes. If we can't get a common 45 then it drops to common artist & failing that common label. It's interesting because things that you think are a give in are not kept in the collection by some people because they are either too common, or not representative of their favorite sound. Let lots of "I don't own that" followed by "how can you not own that" ensue You have to currently have the 45 in question filed, pressings don't matter so long as you can find it on 45 in your collection.

I'll get the ball rolling, does anyone here not have:

The Supremes "Baby Love"

The Temptations "My Girl"

???

ps. if you don't collect 45s please don't say no to everything just to wreck it like I think some people were doing on the other board.

mark

Those are the only three you have or the three you don't

ROD

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by modernsoulsucks

Those are the only three you have or the three you don't

ROD

i have them

mark

Sorry Rod, just having my tea too.

Here's what we're left with then. Has everybody got these?

Weston, Kim - Helpless (Gordy)

Randolph, Barbara - I Got a Feeling (Soul)

Ellis, Shirley - Soul Time (Columbia)

Randolph, Barbara - I Got a Feeling (Soul) YES!

Weston, Kim - Helpless (Gordy) NO!

Ellis, Shirley - Soul Time (Columbia) NO!

Sorry Rod, just having my tea too.

Here's what we're left with then. Has everybody got these?

Weston, Kim - Helpless (Gordy)

Randolph, Barbara - I Got a Feeling (Soul)

Ellis, Shirley - Soul Time (Columbia)

yes

yes

yes

and just realised I have got Jack montgomery on Kent (sorry was thown with Godz large list, I thought we were going down OV road!)

P

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by paup-ine

Right,

so Jack Montgomery is back in and Barbara Randolph is hanging on by the skin of her teeth.

Hope Rod's back soon: this is well beyond my organisational skills.

Right,

so Jack Montgomery is back in and Barbara Randolph is hanging on by the skin of her teeth.

Hope Rod's back soon: this is well beyond my organisational skills.

Has anyone mentioned Bob & Earl? Harlem.

P

I've lost tarck a bit as well while eating. I think (although I'll do the maths later) we're down to just Jack Montgomery again as I don't have Barbara Randolph.

I haven't got Jack Montgomery!

P

Lose my previous comment. Back to ZERO

I've lost tarck a bit as well while eating. I think (although I'll do the maths later) we're down to just Jack Montgomery again as I don't have Barbara Randolph.

Ok lets add Harlem Shuffle.

Actually let's not - I only have the fast Mirwood sounding version on one the 'Joy' label "Keep The Faith" albums from early 70s.

Just Babs then

Ok lets add Harlem Shuffle.

Actually let's not - I only have the fast Mirwood sounding version on one the 'Joy' label "Keep The Faith" albums from early 70s.

Just Babs then

No Godz, Neil (TSU) doesn't have Babs.

Zero it is then!

Tsu has discounted B Randolph and Pauline has reinstated Jack M (I think)

I reckon Rod is gonna be really cross when he comes back and we've not reached a consensus.

So, what if I throw in "Footsee"?

All in favour say aye!

Tsu has discounted B Randolph and Pauline has reinstated Jack M (I think)

Yeah - I seem to have added Jack and then taken him out again

Told you I couldn't do this

I reckon Rod is gonna be really cross when he comes back and we've not reached a consensus.

So, what if I throw in "Footsee"?

All in favour say aye!

I've actually got a Roulette copy that I can't sell

I reckon Rod is gonna be really cross when he comes back and we've not reached a consensus.

So, what if I throw in "Footsee"?

All in favour say aye!

...er, nay. Got it on a CD, but that's enough 'Footsee' for me. Never owned it on any vinyl format.

I reckon Rod is gonna be really cross when he comes back and we've not reached a consensus.

So, what if I throw in "Footsee"?

All in favour say aye!

Don't wanna be here when Rod returns

...er, nay. Got it on a CD, but that's enough 'Footsee' for me. Never owned it on any vinyl format.

Me neither.

Right then.

I'm going home poorly before he gets back!

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by Sean Hampsey

Looks like Jack is still in the running (and I am embarrassed to say) got a Pye Footsee (covered over I might add!!)

P

So just Jack then,

What about Harold Melvin - Get Out

So just Jack then,

What about Harold Melvin - Get Out

and Jimmy James - A Man Like Me?

P

and Jimmy James - A Man Like Me?

P

Harold Melvin has already been knocked out. Jimmy James is rubbish.

Harold Melvin has already been knocked out. Jimmy James is rubbish.

Is that a pre-requisite? Mustn't be rubbish

Harold Melvin has already been knocked out. Jimmy James is rubbish.

Oh Godz!

What about Ernie Johnson - Big Man Cry?

or

Earl Grant - Hide Nor Hair?

P

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by paup-ine

Is that a pre-requisite? Mustn't be rubbish

Not really - I fessed up to Footsie!

Just teasing really, but I haven't got it anyway.

Hey - while Rod's away shall we pile up all the chairs in the middle of the class room?

Not really - I fessed up to Footsie!

Just teasing really, but I haven't got it anyway.

Hey - while Rod's away shall we pile up all the chairs in the middle of the class room?

You can, might as well coz you're in for it anyway

Not really - I fessed up to Footsie!

Just teasing really, but I haven't got it anyway.

Hey - while Rod's away shall we pile up all the chairs in the middle of the class room?

I won't tell, if you won't. Who put that bag of flour on the door?

P

Oh Godz!

What about Ernie Johnson - Big Man Cry?

or

Earl Grant - Hide Nor Hair?

P

I don't think you're supposed to add one until you say you ain't got one. But letting you off, No to Ernie but yes to Earl.

Actually I've just realised that I don't understand Rod's criteria for the ones he left in out of the Top 500.

Anyone get it?

You can, might as well coz you're in for it anyway

GRASSS!!!!

I don't think you're supposed to add one until you say you ain't got one. But letting you off, No to Ernie but yes to Earl.

Actually I've just realised that I don't understand Rod's criteria for the ones he left in out of the Top 500.

Anyone get it?

Thought they were all discounted, also thought you could add a title if those still 'live' are below 3?

I don't think you're supposed to add one until you say you ain't got one. But letting you off, No to Ernie but yes to Earl.

Actually I've just realised that I don't understand Rod's criteria for the ones he left in out of the Top 500.

Anyone get it?

Sorry sir! Forgot my place.

P

GRASSS!!!!

Rather that than be in your shoes later

Thought they were all discounted, also thought you could add a title if those still 'live' are below 3?

If you look he seemed to just chose a section from 300 and odd to 400 and odd, presumably deleting the ones he doesn't own out of that section.

I just PM'd him anyway cos I can't tell anymore if I'm a pupil or a student teacher but I need a wee and might cry soon....

Rather that than be in your shoes later

Missss!! Bully!!!!!

Looks like Jack is still in the running (and I am embarrassed to say) got a Pye Footsee (covered over I might add!!)

P

No no no...(cue emoticon for pulling yer hair out) You said earlier that you didn't have Jack. Can we move onto 70's records 'cos I have a lot of them?

No no no...(cue emoticon for pulling yer hair out) You said earlier that you didn't have Jack. Can we move onto 70's records 'cos I have a lot of them?

Then she said she did, 70's? you better stand with Godz and wait for Rod

Right now. Everyone pay attention...including the naughty ones at the back. Here's the list of NO's so far..... there will be more when I make my way through the top 500 as I'm definitely a 70's person

Ace Spectrum - Dont send nobody else

Contours - A little misunderstanding

Various - Wade in the water

Showstoppers - Houseparty

Bettye Swann - Make Me Yours

Barbara Acklin - Am I The Same Girl

Edwin Starr - SOS

Bobby Hebb - Love love love

Tony Clarke - Landslide

JJ Barnes - Please let me in

JJ Barnes - Real Humdinger

Laura Lee - To win your heart

patti austin - are we ready for love

nancy wilson - end of our love

jackie wilson - i've lost you

Dells - Run for cover

Frankie Beverly - If that's what...

Platters - Sweet Sweet Loving

Platters - Washed Ashore

The Winstons - Color him father

The Supremes - Baby Love

The Temptations - My Girl

Spyder Turner - I Can't Make It Anymore

Al Wilson - The Snake

Darrell Banks - Open The Door To Your Heart

Temptations - Ain't too proud to beg

Rufus Thomas - Walking The Dog

Artistics - Im gonna miss you

Jamo Thomas - I Spy For The FBI

R Dean Taylor - There's A Ghost In My House

Showstoppers - Ain't Nothing But A House Party

Chuck Wood - Seven Days Too Long

Kim Weston - Helpless

Frank Wilson - Do I Love You (Indeed I Do) [not US obviously ]

Cliff Nobles & Co - The Horse

Jackie Wilson - I Get The Sweetest Feeling

Impressions - You've been cheatin

Impressions - Can't satisfy

Edwin Starr - Agent 00-Soul

Edwin Starr - I Have Faith In You

CODs - Michael

Spellbinders - Help me

Curtis Mayfield - Move on up

Jackie Wilson - Whispers getting louder

Isley Brothers - I guess I'll always love you

Isley Brothers - Behind a painted smile

Aretha Franklin - I say a little prayer

Formations - At The Top Of The Stairs

Willie Mitchell - The Champion

Troy Dodds - Try My Love

The Showstoppers - Ain't Nothin' But A Houseparty/What Can A Man Do

Bettye Swann - Make Me Yours

The Bandwagon - Breakin' Down The Walls Of Heartache

Marvin Gaye - What's Going On

Marvin Gaye - I Heard it Through the Grapevine

Anne d'andrea - dont stop lookin'

Nancy ames - i dont want to talk about it

gloria jones - tainted love

er......Clive Dunn - Grandad

Millionaires Never for me

Bobby Hebb - Sunny

Fuller Bros - Time's a wastin'

Jeff Perry - Love Don't Come No Stronger

Chairmen Of The Board - Give Me Just A Little More Time

Marvin Gaye - Little Darling

Bobby Bland "Shoes" or "Yum Yum Tree"?

Clara Hardy on Tuna or Jackie Day on Phelectron

Lou Johnson - Unsatisfied

Alexander Patton - A Lil Lovin Sometimes

Hoagy Lands - Next in Line

What about Ernie Johnson - Big Man Cry

Earl Grant - Hide Nor Hair

Jimmy James - A Man Like Me

Harold Melvin - Get Out

Wigans Chosen Few - Footsee

Archie Bell Here I go

Billy Butler - Right Track

Jack Montgomery - Dear Beloved

Right now. Everyone pay attention...including the naughty ones at the back. Here's the list of NO's so far..... there will be more when I make my way through the top 500 as I'm definitely a 70's person

Ace Spectrum - Dont send nobody else

Contours - A little misunderstanding

Various - Wade in the water

Showstoppers - Houseparty

Bettye Swann - Make Me Yours

Barbara Acklin - Am I The Same Girl

Edwin Starr - SOS

Bobby Hebb - Love love love

Tony Clarke - Landslide

JJ Barnes - Please let me in

JJ Barnes - Real Humdinger

Laura Lee - To win your heart

patti austin - are we ready for love

nancy wilson - end of our love

jackie wilson - i've lost you

Dells - Run for cover

Frankie Beverly - If that's what...

Platters - Sweet Sweet Loving

Platters - Washed Ashore

The Winstons - Color him father

The Supremes - Baby Love

The Temptations - My Girl

Spyder Turner - I Can't Make It Anymore

Al Wilson - The Snake

Darrell Banks - Open The Door To Your Heart

Temptations - Ain't too proud to beg

Rufus Thomas - Walking The Dog

Artistics - Im gonna miss you

Jamo Thomas - I Spy For The FBI

R Dean Taylor - There's A Ghost In My House

Showstoppers - Ain't Nothing But A House Party

Chuck Wood - Seven Days Too Long

Kim Weston - Helpless

Frank Wilson - Do I Love You (Indeed I Do) [not US obviously ]

Cliff Nobles & Co - The Horse

Jackie Wilson - I Get The Sweetest Feeling

Impressions - You've been cheatin

Impressions - Can't satisfy

Edwin Starr - Agent 00-Soul

Edwin Starr - I Have Faith In You

CODs - Michael

Spellbinders - Help me

Curtis Mayfield - Move on up

Jackie Wilson - Whispers getting louder

Isley Brothers - I guess I'll always love you

Isley Brothers - Behind a painted smile

Aretha Franklin - I say a little prayer

Formations - At The Top Of The Stairs

Willie Mitchell - The Champion

Troy Dodds - Try My Love

The Showstoppers - Ain't Nothin' But A Houseparty/What Can A Man Do

Bettye Swann - Make Me Yours

The Bandwagon - Breakin' Down The Walls Of Heartache

Marvin Gaye - What's Going On

Marvin Gaye - I Heard it Through the Grapevine

Anne d'andrea - dont stop lookin'

Nancy ames - i dont want to talk about it

gloria jones - tainted love

er......Clive Dunn - Grandad

Millionaires Never for me

Bobby Hebb - Sunny

Fuller Bros - Time's a wastin'

Jeff Perry - Love Don't Come No Stronger

Chairmen Of The Board - Give Me Just A Little More Time

Marvin Gaye - Little Darling

Bobby Bland "Shoes" or "Yum Yum Tree"?

Clara Hardy on Tuna or Jackie Day on Phelectron

Lou Johnson - Unsatisfied

Alexander Patton - A Lil Lovin Sometimes

Hoagy Lands - Next in Line

What about Ernie Johnson - Big Man Cry

Earl Grant - Hide Nor Hair

Jimmy James - A Man Like Me

Harold Melvin - Get Out

Wigans Chosen Few - Footsee

Archie Bell Here I go

Billy Butler - Right Track

Jack Montgomery - Dear Beloved

Still in I believe

Then she said she did, 70's? you better stand with Godz and wait for Rod

70s soul? I'd be better off with twisted oldies, preferably white pop with slightly a psychedelic edge, Burning Bush, The Present, Susan Farrar and so on. Got all of them. Not suggesting they'd be appropriate for this thread mind you.

Is it obvious that I've abdicated by the way?

Still in I believe

Yep - Jack's in.

Yep - Jack's in.

Is this the same as 'abdicates'?

Edited March 31, 200916 yr by Pete60

Yep - Jack's in.

So am I allowed to add anymore now that Ernie Johnson is out?

Carl Hall - Mean It Baby

P

So am I allowed to add anymore now that Ernie Johnson is out?

Carl Hall - Mean It Baby

P

70s soul? I'd be better off with twisted oldies, preferably white pop with slightly a psychedelic edge, Burning Bush, The Present, Susan Farrar and so on. Got all of them. Not suggesting they'd be appropriate for this thread mind you.

Is it obvious that I've abdicated by the way?

I have none of them...is that a NO then......owww me brain hurts

Right now. Everyone pay attention...including the naughty ones at the back.

You wanna sort Pete60 out sir. He keeps trying to make me mess about.

Tomangoes??

P

Carl Hall - Mean It Baby

P

NO from me.

Can I suggest:

George Wilson - Here stands a man

Tomangoes??

P

No I think it's TSU Tomatoes.

Please pay attention

You wanna sort Pete60 out sir. He keeps trying to make me mess about.

Any more of your lip and you'll both be be sent to detention

NO from me.

Can I suggest:

George Wilson - Here stands a man

No sorry

Benny Troy?

P