On 1/13/2018 at 18:13, Pete S said:

Why is it?  He's right.

Just because someone dislikes one particular record cannot, and does not mean, that they don’t know the meaning of northern soul. It’s a silly thing to say. 

Just because I don’t like Pukka pies does not mean that I don’t know what a pie is. 

It is,  well spotted👏👍

1 hour ago, britishbarry said:

I thought that was Lonnie Liston Smith 😀😀

 

16 hours ago, Spain pete said:

?LLS ? ????lm waiting. Gimme

 

Personally,I'd be more than happy to sit and listen to Gil Scott's entire back catalogue.

Id probably start with the 'Im So Much More Than Just A Northern Soul Artist' deluxe Box Set.

Dunno about the expanding the mind bit tho...it's been 'expanded ' in my younger days enough already thanks !

31 minutes ago, Spain pete said:

It is,  well spotted👏👍

 

 

 

What other tracks, apart from the bottle, and please list or include a youtube link, have ever been played at Northern Soul all nighters regularly from the former Celtic player's son's back catalogue? 

Ed

10 hours ago, tomangoes said:

If it was indeed Dave Godin who actually coined the phrase 'Northern Soul', and considering he was a pure soul fan, being subjected to SCRATCHY, COMPARED TO WHAT, GREEN DOOR, and such like, was he was actually taking the P*** ?

 

Ed

No Ed from what I remember hearing he named it "northern soul" because soul fans from the north of England were visiting London, often to see their football teams play at the weekend. and were popping into the Soul City shop buying uptrmpo soul records. Made it easier for staff to sell records to the northern fans who were looking for that certain dance beat.

Cheers Paul

Edited January 17, 20187 yr by soul shrews
spellpng !

Sounds like a bit of nudge nudge wink wink to me....

Pity we can't ask Dave RIP what he really meant...uptempo soul, in its truest form ? Or the weird and wonderful uptempo sounds that these Northerners like.

Being a Motown man, I wonder what he thought of stuff like there's a ghost in my house and the night??

Anybody on here knew him well? 

Ed

43 minutes ago, tomangoes said:

 

Anybody on here knew him well? 

Ed

Yes,I  knew Dave Godin.

He was good friends with both of my parents in the 1980's and he visited the house on many occasions.

He was a lovely fella too, btw.

Edited January 17, 20187 yr by Soulsides

2 hours ago, tomangoes said:

What other tracks, apart from the bottle, and please list or include a youtube link, have ever been played at Northern Soul all nighters regularly from the former Celtic player's son's back catalogue? 

Ed

Lady day and John Coltrane has had plenty of spins in the upfront scene. sorry will try to post a link later. 

3 hours ago, soul shrews said:

No Ed from what I remember hearing he named it "northern soul" because soul fans from the north of England were visiting London, often to see their football teams play at the weekend. and were popping into the Soul City shop buying uptrmpo soul records. Made it easier for staff to sell records to the northern fans who were looking for that certain dance beat.

Cheers Paul

this is true I think, I've got an interview he gave to a soul magazine stuck in the garage somewhere

yup

 

Edited January 17, 20187 yr by Shufflin
facts

1 hour ago, geeselad said:

Lady day and John Coltrane has had plenty of spins in the upfront scene. sorry will try to post a link later. 

Hope you do, would love to know what the Coltrane tune is.

"I had started to notice that northern football fans who were in London to follow their team were coming into the store to buy records, but they weren’t interested in the latest developments in the black American chart. I devised the name as a shorthand sales term. It was just to say ‘if you’ve got customers from the north, don’t waste time playing them records currently in the US black chart, just play them what they like - ‘Northern Soul’."[5] 

Quote from Dave Godin's Wikipedia page.

Edited January 17, 20187 yr by Soulsides

1 hour ago, shufflin said:

this is true I think, I've got an interview he gave to a soul magazine stuck in the garage somewhere

yup

 

But he does not give an example of what he means?

He says

Don't play them new records from the American chart, play them these sort Northern Soul records.

Ignore the backing music, that's added later along with everything else.

I still think there's a slight hint of sarcasm.

Maybe there is an extended interview where he explains.

Ed

1 hour ago, middleman said:

Hope you do, would love to know what the Coltrane tune is

The youtube file of this is currently on the Record Club 2018, 50 Years of Rare Soul thread

1 hour ago, middleman said:

Hope you do, would love to know what the Coltrane tune is.

Same song 

Here you go,  christ I've amazed myself, posted a link from my phone! 

Killa was the first I heard play it about 10 years back in the back room of the King's hall. 

Edited January 17, 20187 yr by geeselad

The 'upfront scene' ?

I need to get out more.............

That track is about as on the edge of Northern Soul as this old Mecca tune. Never heard it played out either.

Ed

On 17/01/2018 at 00:26, givemesoul said:

I'm out of this discussion too many self righteous ppl who think their soul is the only soul slag off david & the giants next or epitome of sound then i'll be back

On 17/01/2018 at 23:35, geeselad said:

Here you go,  christ I've amazed myself, posted a link from my phone! 

Killa was the first I heard play it about 10 years back in the back room of the King's hall. 

Interesting. So a song that was known to millions of people with absolutley no connection to the northern soul scene in the decades since its release is played on the NS "upfront" scene presumeably as cutting edge?

Like The Bottle it's essentially a jazz record,  albeit contemporary jazz fusion of it's time. 

Edited January 19, 20187 yr by maslar
typo

2 hours ago, maslar said:

Interesting. So a song that was known to millions of people with absolutley no connection to the northern soul scene in the decades since its release is played on the NS "upfront" scene presumeably as cutting edge?

Like The Bottle it's essentially a jazz record,  albeit contemporary jazz fusion of it's time. 

the question was has anything else by Gill played, didnt realise I needed to justify its merits as 'upfront' as well. Well its fresh to the Northern scene anyway. I sposse it a bit like the oldies crowd playing Mel Torme and 'baby your out of time'.