Ged Parker Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 It's a soul night FFS, one that caters for the local crowd, Colin was/would have been a draw, if there wasn't a massive amount of complaints by the punters there, why is it being debated here (again) does it matter that much? No! Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Mike Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 ok the blog poster has had his say, people have had a chance to reply/discuss the points that he raised all starting to get a bit repetitive so looking at closing this thread very shortly just so aware cheers mike Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Roger Williams Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 Actually, I think Steve L is correct. Colin Curtis may have once been a great and innovative northern soul DJ. He may be a great modern soul DJ. He may have fantastic knowledge of the subject and rather good musical taste. BUT, without the records, he is no longer an authentic northern soul DJ at a dedicated northern soul event. Particularly one where other DJs do in fact have the records in their boxes. And let's face it, reiterating post 43, it wouldn't be so onerous a task to actually obtain the records which Colin played at the Swallow would it? Just out of curiosity, were you one of the DJ's who had the records in their boxes at this gig? Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Guest Seagrave Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 It's a soul night FFS, one that caters for the local crowd, Colin was/would have been a draw, if there wasn't a massive amount of complaints by the punters there, why is it being debated here (again) does it matter that much? Winnie, the reason it is being debated on here is because the topic starter decided (out of the clear blue sky, from a Soul Source point of view) that he wanted to mount a defence of Colin Curtis. The thread was not started by anyone complaining about Colin's method of DJing. The topic starter provided a link to a piece which stated: 'Last friday at the Swallow Hotel in Gateshead, emerging as the best of the North East nostalgia nights, he was criticised for committing the cardinal sin playing the incorrect variety of plastic, variously described as crap and disgraceful.' This implies that there were indeed significant complaints, although they were made elsewhere. There is, though, clearly a debate to be had as it has engaged a number of opinions and comments. Note to Mike: it would be a shame to close the thread as it is topical, thought provoking, controversial, generally 'on-topic', and clearly interesting to many Soul-Sourcers. It also hasn't degenerated into the types of personal insults which often occur elsewhere. Let's see where it goes! Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Guest Seagrave Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 Just out of curiosity, were you one of the DJ's who had the records in their boxes at this gig? No I wasn't, so nothing personal about my opinions (on this occasion!). Just points of principle. I also hope, from the post you quoted at least, there is no doubt about my admiration and respect for what Colin Curtis has contributed to the northern soul scene. Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Ged Parker Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 Let's see where it goes! It'll go the same way as every other similar thread. No one ever changes their mind and no DJ has every changed his methods as a result of these threads. Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Mike Posted June 20, 2012 Share Posted June 20, 2012 (edited) Winnie, the reason it is being debated on here is because the topic starter decided (out of the clear blue sky, from a Soul Source point of view) that he wanted to mount a defence of Colin Curtis. The thread was not started by anyone complaining about Colin's method of DJing. The topic starter provided a link to a piece which stated: 'Last friday at the Swallow Hotel in Gateshead, emerging as the best of the North East nostalgia nights, he was criticised for committing the cardinal sin playing the incorrect variety of plastic, variously described as crap and disgraceful.' This implies that there were indeed significant complaints, although they were made elsewhere. There is, though, clearly a debate to be had as it has engaged a number of opinions and comments. Note to Mike: it would be a shame to close the thread as it is topical, thought provoking, controversial, generally 'on-topic', and clearly interesting to many Soul-Sourcers. It also hasn't degenerated into the types of personal insults which often occur elsewhere. Let's see where it goes! if you do want to discuss the actual playing of various formats then it be best if start a new thread the singling out and constant reference to one person and one event as the focus for the discussion doesn't sit well with me what ever your views on it all, it does go on elsewhere and other "well known" djs do do it, and so do feel that any further discussion should reflect that rather than its current state as said am closing this, as feel needed if do wish to discuss the general points raised then feel free to start a new thread, thanks mike Edited June 20, 2012 by mike Link to comment Social source share More sharing options...
Recommended Posts