I've not owned one of these but I think it's time I did. There seems to be a bewildering array of labels. Can anyone put them in some sort of order of rarityness ?

Edited February 6, 201510 yr by Chris L

They are different mixes too mate!

They are different mixes too mate!

 

I was afraid of that, any advice welcome.

I've got the top 3, Best mix for me is the Mary Jane, but the version of Call Me on the flip is better on the Carrie one

They are different mixes too mate!

 

Inconsiderate b*stards making us buy all 5 pressings! 

 

Ian D 

Edited February 7, 201510 yr by pikeys dog
swearing - work filters

Any  DJ who talks over the drum intro to this should have his mike stuck where the sun don't shine !

Don't suppose anyone has a clip of ALL sides just to compare - Richard - Premium Stuff?

Rarest is Orange Carrie which is the original first release.....Mary Jane release has more horns and " ooos" from the backing singers....Green Carrie is 70s legit reissue...Jameco is a legit release also.

They're all brilliant....but my fav is the original orange Carrie release...bit more sparse and raw..you also get the brilliant "call me" on the Carrie release as Tony said.

Edited February 6, 201510 yr by Dennisoul

Rarity - Orange Carrie

- Mary Jane

- Jameco

- Green Carrie

There is a United Sound acetate with the same sides type written on label.

I like the look of that Orange one

I like the look of that Orange one

I do. At first glance I thought the writing looks black, but it is dark blue!

Is "Call Me" different on the Carrie and Jameco releases? How so? (It didn't come out on Mary Jane, as far as I can tell.)

"Call Me" should be the same version on Carrie and Jameco- when the record became 

popular in New York, the record was leased to Jameco.

I do. At first glance I thought the writing looks black, but it is dark blue!

I thought it might be a boot at first,but on closer inspection it's that lovely blue print and RCA vinyl pressing.

 

weird but wonderful

"Call Me" should be the same version on Carrie and Jameco- when the record became 

popular in New York, the record was leased to Jameco.

Been a century since I compared them, sure the Jameco 45 sounds "quiet" compared to the Carrie release

I thought it might be a boot at first,but on closer inspection it's that lovely blue print and RCA vinyl pressing.

 

weird but wonderful

Same as Clifford Binns

Same as Clifford Binns

 

Tony

 

Which Clifford Binns?

Tony

 

Which Clifford Binns?

"You Got To Help Me" also repressed on the green label

"You Got To Help Me" also repressed on the green label

 

Was this RCA Pressing?

Was this RCA Pressing?

The orange one yes, consecutive number to Ed Hamilton, label owner re-pressed both on the green label years later. 

The orange one yes, consecutive number to Ed Hamilton, label owner re-pressed both on the green label years later. 

Clifford Binns - Great record...always used to use it to test my disco equipment out - then flip it aswell.

Edited February 7, 201510 yr by RUDZY

Clifford Binns - Great record...always used to use it to test my disco equipment out - then flip it aswell.

Got my orange Clifford off our friend from Melton for £30 over 20 years ago, that was cheap then!

Don't suppose anyone has a clip of ALL sides just to compare - Richard - Premium Stuff?

 

I have the orange Carrie, Mary Jane and Jameco - never bothered with the green Carrie.

 

Haven't done soundclips for them all though Jim.

 

Cheers

 

Richard

Thanks Richards - your standards are slipping - lol!!!

Got my orange Clifford off our friend from Melton for £30 over 20 years ago, that was cheap then!

 

Looks like £100.00 nowadays ?

Looks like £100.00 nowadays ?

MoRE !

Looks like £100.00 nowadays ?

 

I would have thought more too, nearer 300?

Edited February 8, 201510 yr by chalky

I would have thought more too, nearer 300?

If you can find one!

I would have thought more too, nearer 300?

 

according to Pipsqueak you can pick one up for about £100.00

according to Pipsqueak you can pick one up for about £100.00

£100 for an Orange label first issue of Clifford Binns! I'll have 3 please!

Not forgetting this one 

I do. At first glance I thought the writing looks black, but it is dark blue!

Just like the clifford binns then. Cool!

£100 for an Orange label first issue of Clifford Binns! I'll have 3 please!

 

https://www.popsike.com/Edward-Hamilton-Fifes-45-IM-GONNA-LOVE-YOU-CALL-ME-JAMECO-nice-VG-to-VG/381126769575.html

 

https://www.popsike.com/Edward-Hamilton-Arabians-45-IM-GONNA-LOVE-YOU-LET-ME-KNOW-MARY-JANE-M/381117828656.html

 

https://www.popsike.com/Im-Gonna-Love-You-Edward-Hamilton-Jameco/161450689297.html

https://www.popsike.com/Edward-Hamilton-Fifes-45-IM-GONNA-LOVE-YOU-CALL-ME-JAMECO-nice-VG-to-VG/381126769575.html

 

https://www.popsike.com/Edward-Hamilton-Arabians-45-IM-GONNA-LOVE-YOU-LET-ME-KNOW-MARY-JANE-M/381117828656.html

 

https://www.popsike.com/Im-Gonna-Love-You-Edward-Hamilton-Jameco/161450689297.html

 

None of those are an orange Carrie?  You replied to Tony's quote about the orange one?

None of those are an orange Carrie?  You replied to Tony's quote about the orange one?

 

Right got it. Don't really mind what colour label is as long as it's an original. I did see an orange one for £125.00, albeit sold some years ago, nearly treble in price in 4.5 years ?

Edited February 9, 201510 yr by Chris L