How many records are considered to be Northern Soul?

 

Realise that's an impossible question - especially given the wider diversity of sounds played these days.  Just a fun, frivolous thread really!

 

What is the size of the treasure trove? 

Edited April 24, 201510 yr by Dayo

I think its far to subjective. 

You could argue that the JM price guide would be a good starting point and even then they'd be arguments over what might be an R&B record etc and what is 'Northern', plus the countless new plays and nuances in what can be categorised as a the northern sound. 
An example that comes to mind is 'Mark Putney - Don't come around here anymore/Today's Man on Ovide. I'd argue both sides are...funky-northern, ha! Some would say something else. 

Thought there were 500?

Edited April 24, 201510 yr by John Reed

Thought there were 500?

 

That many?  Must be a shed load of new doscoveries 

Once talking to Tim Brown about this, maybe 20 years ago.

Tim said then no more than 10,000 max.

Got to be over 100,000 ?  

 

JM Price Guide 5 states it includes 80,000 Titles................ 

 

 

Got to be over 100,000 ?  

 

JM Price Guide 5 states it includes 80,000 Titles................ 

 

 

F**k me, there must be about 70.000 records l have not heard yet!

Which clubs are playing em, count me in l will be there.

That's now until l die taken care of music wise.

F**k me, there must be about 70.000 records l have not heard yet!

Which clubs are playing em, count me in l will be there.

That's now until l die taken care of music wise.

 

They are called Upfront clubs Dave.

F**k me, there must be about 70.000 records l have not heard yet!

Which clubs are playing em, count me in l will be there.

That's now until l die taken care of music wise.

Dave

The "Up Front" ones........sorry that's another thread

Cheers

Martyn

They are called Upfront clubs Dave.

Kev

beat me to it

Cheers

Martyn

How many records are considered to be Northern Soul?

 

Realise that's an impossible question - especially given the wider diversity of sounds played these days.  Just a fun, frivolous thread really!

 

What is the size of the treasure trove? 

Considering all the records I've seen branded as 'Northern Soul' on eBay, I reckon at least seven million, possibly more.

Once talking to Tim Brown about this, maybe 20 years ago.

Tim said then no more than 10,000 max.

 

It might be an urban myth, but I heard somewhere that Tim Brown had set himself the challenge of owning at least one copy of every 45 considered northern?

80k titles is about 40k records.....

It might be an urban myth, but I heard somewhere that Tim Brown had set himself the challenge of owning at least one copy of every 45 considered northern?

Is that released north Of Watford.. It might be a new variation.we have that many now., modern.rare, r n b, popcorn, upfront, oldies, funky edge. (Is that a district of alderley edge. )all a load of bollocks. Sorry for off topic rant.

Good place to start would be how many labels there's been .... that have released records that have been considered northern soul

Steve

109642 northern soul records,at the last count but I can't for the life of me remember who counted them.

Keep on counting on. ML

It might be an urban myth, but I heard somewhere that Tim Brown had set himself the challenge of owning at least one copy of every 45 considered northern?

At one time it was his goal.

It might be an urban myth, but I heard somewhere that Tim Brown had set himself the challenge of owning at least one copy of every 45 considered northern?

His goal was every "soul" record actually. Tim likes all genres not just northern.

If there is allegedly so many 1000's then why the bleeding hell have we been subjected to the same monotonous shite week after week for years and years at venues lacking progression. Surely if you're a resident DJ you'd want to step away from the predictable and give the rest of the line up a whooping behind the decks, just as much as you want to wow the punters. I'd be interested to hear people's general consensus on WHAT is worthy of the label NORTHERN SOUL??

Edited May 26, 201510 yr by Mrs M

If there is allegedly so many 1000's then why the bleeding hell have we been subjected to the same monotonous shite week after week for years and years at venues lacking progression. Surely if you're a resident DJ you'd want to step away from the predictable and give the rest of the line a whooping behind the decks, just as much as you want to wow the punters. I'd be interested to hear people's general consensus on WHAT is worthy of the label NORTHERN SOUL??

I always used to look forward to going out and listening to a different DJ at a different venue play their big track knowing I wouldn't hear it everywhere I went. At present you can hear any track you want EVERYWHERE you go because if the DJ hasn't got it he will have it next month. Now why is that? and that is the reason we are hearing the same old everywhere.