Jump to content
Soul Source

Fave version: Oh, Lord. What are you doing to me?

Posted

A little while back, a friend here in NL very kindly gifted me a copy of Dionne Warwick's Disques Vogue French EP he found in the wild and which contains her sublime take on the classic Luther Dixon-penned "Oh Lord, what are you doing to me?" I have to say I've been rather haunted by her version ever since - Dionne seems to bring the right depth of emotional fragility to the song, certainly in a way that appeals to me.

Numerous other versions out there - Big Maybelle being the original and first call, of course - but what's your fave take?

 

    • Up vote 2
    • Replies 15
    • Views 1.6k
    • Created
    • Last Reply

    Most active in this topic

    Most Popular Posts

    • Benji
      Benji

      There are a number of cover versions, Dionne Warwick, Maxine Brown, Freddie North, Tommy Hunt, Brenda & The Tabulations. Each one is good in its own right but none come close to Big Maybelle IMO.

    • Wheelsville1
      Wheelsville1

      Big Maybelle followed by Maxine Brown.

    • Jamesh
      Jamesh

      Freddie North for me

    Featured Replies

    1 hour ago, Amsterdam Russ said:

    A little while back, a friend here in NL very kindly gifted me a copy of Dionne Warwick's Disques Vogue French EP he found in the wild and which contains her sublime take on the classic Luther Dixon-penned "Oh Lord, what are you doing to me?" I have to say I've been rather haunted by her version ever since - Dionne seems to bring the right depth of emotional fragility to the song, certainly in a way that appeals to me.

    Numerous other versions out there - Big Maybelle being the original and first call, of course - but what's your fave take?

     

    Big Maybelle followed by Maxine Brown.

    • Up vote 2

    Dionne's orchestration is way too light for me, Maxine almost Bossa-Nova tempo makes it almost another tune where Big Maybell's strong, deep felt and grave voice fits the composition like a glove. I'm not a Dionne lover so that's out and Maxine can be a fantastic singer with the right gear. Only less here for me.

    • Popular Post

    There are a number of cover versions, Dionne Warwick, Maxine Brown, Freddie North, Tommy Hunt, Brenda & The Tabulations. Each one is good in its own right but none come close to Big Maybelle IMO.

    • Up vote 4

    If I was pushed, I'd go for Tommy Hunt's version, Big Maybelle in second, Freddie's is ok, if you get the LP, it’s on there, the common one on Abet, rather than shelling out on the 45.  Tommy Hunt here, best version by far...

    Big Maybelle for sure. The only version that brings tears to my eyes. 

    • Up vote 1

    Get involved with Soul Source

    Go to topic listing

    Advert via Google