Jump to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.
Soul Source

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.
Soul Source

Eddie Holman - She's Wanted

Posted

As an alternative to the Larry Clinton monster, I quite like the Eddie Holman version of 'She's wanted'
Does anyone know the origins of this version? Was it an album only track or was it released on 7" before

the 'Grapevine' release? and if so what label?

Thanks

Edited by Northern Soul UK

  • Replies 39
  • Views 5.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Most active in this topic

Most Popular Posts

Featured Replies

I only know it from the Grapevine 45.

It's definitely not on the Goldmine/Soul suppl L.P that came out several years ago featuring a lot of his unissued stuff. 

As an alternative to the Larry Clinton monster, I quite like the Eddie Holman version of 'She's wanted'

Does anyone know the origins of this version? Was it an album only track or was it released on 7" before

the 'Grapevine' release? and if so what label?

Thanks

Unreleased.version as far as I recall, before grapevine put.it out

Edited by NEV

I've always assumed it was the demo that Eddie did given that he co-wrote it so it wasn't intended to be released (I guess).

I love the instrumental version...has that gained a legal issue?

Wonder where it came from originally then? Master tape maybe? def' can't see it on any of his albums.

Didn't Andy Rix & Rob Thomas find this or am I dreaming (pissed) again ?

 

Andy mate , where are you ?

 

 

Swifty :thumbsup:

 

p.s. sure I've seen some footage of Eddie singing whilst the acetate was playing , not sure if it wasn't at the same time they found 'World of happiness' ???? :hypo:

Edited by SWIFTY

I've got this on "Soul Beat" single, bought on the scooter scene during the 80's. Think it might be Sister Sledge, Ronnie Dyson or Detroit Prophets version of Suspicion on the other side. Not too sure which as have 2 records on that label (cough - dubious origins - ) from then.

Didn't Andy Rix & Rob Thomas find this or am I dreaming (pissed) again ?

 

Andy mate , where are you ?

 

 

Swifty :thumbsup:

 

p.s. sure I've seen some footage of Eddie singing whilst the acetate was playing , not sure if it wasn't at the same time they found 'World of happiness' ???? :hypo:

 

Yes ... got it from Eddie on a 8" Virtue acetate

 

Andy

I've got this on "Soul Beat" single, bought on the scooter scene during the 80's. Think it might be Sister Sledge, Ronnie Dyson or Detroit Prophets version of Suspicion on the other side. Not too sure which as have 2 records on that label (cough - dubious origins - ) from then.

Different tune, you're talking about 'Where I'm Not Wanted'.

This is about 'She's Wanted In Three States'...

Proper Northern tune. In fact it's a storming northern tune.

 

Innit.

 

Peter

 

:yes:

Edited by Peter99

I have an old Video tape somewhere where he performed She`s wanted on stage. It was in Stafford I think.

Sorry folks, am I missing something here. I dont recall Eddie Holman getting a Grapevine release of "She's Wanted In Three States"... only the Larry Clinton version. Eddie certainly has performed it in the UK as I have it on video but as per previous comment along the same lines... I wouldnt have a clue where it is.

Please clearthis up with a definitive answer as I think I'm losing my marbles :D

 

 

Steve

Aaaahhh... Grapevine 2000, now I didn't think of that series and in fact its the one series I didn't collect. Thank you Mr Supercorsa... I can sleep soundly now :hatsoff2:

 

Steve

  • Author

Actually interesting that is say's (RE) at the side of it? Imagining that means Re-Release, in turn meaning that it has been release perviously?
Which begs the question when, and what on?

theres two versions by eddie holman, the one on grapevine and a better one..  

That's really helpful Marc. :wicked:

 

A better one!

 

Peter

 

:lol:

is there not two versions of the eddie Holman on the cd northern philly(harthon) def two larry but cd not at hand but sure two eddie takes on it

Marc's referring to the unreleased version that Johnny Beggs has been playing that knocks spots off he Grapevine release.....

I have an old Video tape somewhere where he performed She`s wanted on stage. It was in Stafford I think.

didnt he sing  it at lowton, 1999/200

I saw Eddie sing this live many years ago at the Ritz All Nighter in McR and he was shockingly bad

isn't JB's copy still off Andy's acetate ??, sure Andy told me it was !!, so who has the instrumental then ? Andy ??

She's Wanted In Three States instrumental is on this podcast I did if anyone hasn't heard it

 

https://mixcloud.com/mayfairmenthol/northern-soul-unreleased-gems-classic-dancers/

 

Edited by Pete S

  • Author

Well just had to buy the Grapevine copy, from a guy in France for £12.99. I think the 'EH' version is excellent and the inst' in on the 'B' side too I believe so bonus!

Maybe, but mine is much older. Mid 80s.

Hi,

Eddie sang 'She's Wanted' at Stafford. I was not a great fan of live acts but he was amazing. I was looking through records and not concentrating when he started his set and it took me about 20 seconds to realise it was not a DJ playing 'I Surrender'. One of the truly distinctive and great soul voices in my book.

Regards

Ion

  • 3 months later...

didnt he sing  it at lowton, 1999/200

Yes kev murphy bought him over from the states ive heard many a story lol.... kev owns eddie holmans larry clinton red issue

didnt he sing  it at lowton, 1999/200

When Eddie Holman performed at Lowton backed by four members of the Liverpool Philharmonic orchestra it to my mind redefined live acts. It was the greatest performance that I've seen of any live act. Think it was about ninety minutes of unbelievable pure emotion. He described how every record that he performed came about, who he wrote it for. Hey there lonely girl was just like listening to the 45.  I surrender, so special. Wanted in three states. WOW. Where I'm not wanted. You just had to be there. I can't describe the night, no words could do it justice.

 

Steve

yep agree, I was there

When Eddie Holman performed at Lowton backed by four members of the Liverpool Philharmonic orchestra it to my mind redefined live acts. It was the greatest performance that I've seen of any live act. Think it was about ninety minutes of unbelievable pure emotion. He described how every record that he performed came about, who he wrote it for. Hey there lonely girl was just like listening to the 45.  I surrender, so special. Wanted in three states. WOW. Where I'm not wanted. You just had to be there. I can't describe the night, no words could do it justice.

 

Steve

I saw Eddie Holman perform Lonely Girl live - probably at Hinckley. As he was singing it I thought fcuk me can someone really sing like that? Class act indeed.

 

Peter

I saw Eddie Holman perform Lonely Girl live - probably at Hinckley. As he was singing it I thought fcuk me can someone really sing like that? Class act indeed.

 

Peter

 

 

I'll have to dig the photo's out. Great night!

 

Steve

Get involved with Soul Source

Go to topic listing

Advert via Google


Configure browser push notifications
Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.