- Replies 62
- Views 9.6k
- Created
- Last Reply
Most active in this topic
-
hullsoul 6 posts
-
Frankie Crocker 4 posts
-
Pete S 3 posts
-
Patto 3 posts
Most Popular Posts
-
Dance scene. Quite a few wouldn't know a good soul record if it jumped off the decks and hit them
-
You forgot the third option which is a 'social scene', as many I know don't dance and don't really listen or take an interest in the music.
-
Dance scene, otherwise why hold events in venues with dance floors?
After the Lifeline thread & other threads in the past the question I want to ask is it a Dance Scene or Soul Scene we belong to?I would be interested in how others view things?
Over the years I've had one or two heated debates with long term soulie mates & have even shocked one or two with the question as they had never ever considered that they belonged to anything other then a soul scene???Personally I think it's a dance scene first & a soul scene second,my reasoning for thinking that is we cherry pick tunes from many genres of music & why do we do that...........to try to get people dancing.
Yes I know 90% of our music is from Black American which makes it heavily soul based but from the earliest days we absorbed these other types of music in varied amounts to call our own & this has been for no other reason but to keep the dancers excited & happy.
So with other forms of music been played that are not of the soul genre it obviously opens the debate (usually heated & passionate)of should they be played or not,these differences of opinion have been going on in there various forms as long as I've been on the scene which I think is healthy & in a small way works to self police things & usually stops things going too far(maybe others would disagree with that?)
I'm not trying to cause a shouting match about this type of music is shit,that shouldn't be played etc,I'm not saying my view is right I'm just interested how others view the question??